| |
HOW DID WE FIND OUT ABOUT GOD?
I
never cease to be amazed at how difficult it is to get people to
understand why the habit of talking about God is little more than
an exercise in futility. In the essay titled "God" I posed
the question of our first awareness of such an Entity. I'd like
to elaborate somewhat on that question.
It is a sure bet that you did not
come up with the idea on your own. Someone told you about it. And
that someone was no doubt a human being. Everything we know about
God is based upon the words of another mortal.
Unless of course you are prepared
to step forward and claim that God Himself/Herself/ITself told you
(of Himself/Herself/ITself).
Somehow, I don't think you are. Can
you imagine? What would you do if you were in a public place with
a friend, maybe doing some shopping, or having lunch, and your friend,
without warning, were to blurt out, "Hey, look! There's God.
Come on, I want you to meet Him."?
I don't know about you, but if I were
with someone who did that, I'd ask them how exactly they knew it
was God (assuming they were serious about such an outburst). I mean,
does He wear an ID badge?
Which brings me to one of my absolute
favorite thought experiments:
How indeed would you know it was God
if you ever were to meet Him?
It's not like you've met Him before.
So you would have no basis for recognition. A thing must first be
cognized before it can be re-cognized.
The problem is the original cognition.
If you were to come across a ball
of bright light, so bright you couldn't look at it for fear of going
blind, and heard a voice coming from it speaking to you, would you
assume the big ball of light was God? If so, why?
I remember an episode of Star Trek
(Errand of Mercy) wherein Captain Kirk and a Klingon emissary were
on a planet (Organia) where they were having some dealings with
another alien species, whose members were composed of pure energy.
And being composed of pure energy gave them the ability to appear
in any shape they desired. Two members of their species (in human
form) were speaking to Captain Kirk and the Klingon commander when,
all of a sudden, they started to glow and then turn into spheres
of dazzling light, so bright that Captain Kirk and the Klingon had
to shield their eyes.
Spock was also present and responded
with his usual, "Fascinating." He then proceeded to explain
to Captain Kirk and the Klingon that the beings were made of pure
energy, that they were advanced forms of life, “...not as
we know it at all.”
I found it highly interesting that
neither Captain Kirk nor the Klingon - not for a single moment -
suspected that they had just been in the presence of God (or a god).
It was this episode of Star Trek that
gave me the idea for the thought experiment. I was thinking about
it one day, and in very much the same way that Beaver would ask
his big brother, I thought, "Gee, Wally, if a big ball of light
came up to you and talked to you, but wasn't God, just somebody
from another planet, how would you know it was God if He walked
right up to you?"
Good question, Beaver. I'd like to
know that myself. Or, as Wally might put it, "Heck, Beav, I
don't know. Ask dad."
Even if the light told you everything
you ever did, you still couldn't say (with complete assurance) that
it was God. It just so happens that, at this very moment, scientists
are avidly working on the technology that will enable ordinary human
beings to do that very thing. It's called nanotechnology, a downright
ambitious enterprise dedicated to the development of molecular-sized
machines that can do the utterly amazing. Molecular-sized means
of course not visible, which further means that they could be floating
all around and you would never be aware of it; and some of those
machines just might be sophisticated cameras spying on you.
And no sort of God is needed to make
this happen, just technology.
The question bears repeating, but
in a slightly different form: what exactly does a being have to
do in order to be promoted to (considered worthy of) the position
of God?
I honestly can't think of an answer,
which means nothing of course, because if I were to think of an
answer, it would most likely be worthless. It would be my answer,
and what am I? Last time I checked I was just an ordinary human
being, and what the hell do I know about God? When you think about
it, isn't that what it would take to recognize God? I mean, another
God, and that would mean that there would be no God (because there
would be gods).
How could a human point to something
and say it was greater than a human? It truly seems to make some
sort of sense that only God could recognize God. If something were
greater than us, how could we tell? How could we make such a judgement?
What does it even mean to be greater than human? To have the power
to truly make such a determination implies that we are somehow already
greater than us, and thus have the power to recognize such, which
is obviously absurd.
Heck, Beaver ... I don't know what
to say.
|
|